Bukele's Mega-Prison Model Faces Growing Doubts Across Latin America
More than a dozen governments have proposed copying El Salvador's CECOT, but criminologists warn mega-prisons are costly, unproven and unlikely to deliver lasting security.
By Hannah Takahashi ·

With room for up to 40,000 prisoners, sentences of up to 1,000 years and a regime of extreme isolation, El Salvador's Terrorism Confinement Center, or CECOT, has become the emblem of President Nayib Bukele's war on organized crime. About 15,000 inmates are held there, and staged government images show shaved, tattooed prisoners subdued by heavily armed guards.
The prison has also become a reference across the region. More than a dozen Latin American governments have proposed building similar mega-prisons, mostly smaller, but a range of experts consulted by DW question whether such projects are effective or sustainable.
Criminologist Jose Luis Perez Guadalupe, a former Peruvian interior minister and former head of the National Penitentiary Institute, notes that de facto mega-prisons, meaning overcrowded facilities, existed long before Bukele: Lima's Lurigancho Prison, built for 3,000 inmates, has held nearly 11,000 for decades. Since CECOT opened in 2023, though, the term has become tied to maximum security, an association Olga Espinoza, a prison systems academic at the University of Chile's School of Government, calls problematic because it implies the entire prison population requires "extremely severe" punishment.
Putting all prisoners under maximum security would be an inefficient and extremely costly "over-intervention," Espinoza says, requiring investment in infrastructure, technology, specialized staff, anti-corruption measures and reintegration programs. It could also backfire: international evidence indicates that confining people with different profiles together carries a high risk of spreading criminal behavior.
Several of the region's most feared criminal groups were born inside overcrowded prisons: Tren de Aragua in Venezuela; Los Lobos, Los Choneros and Los Tiguerones in Ecuador; and the Primeiro Comando da Capital and Comando Vermelho in Brazil.
Nor does bigger mean cheaper. "There is insufficient evidence to support the claim that building mega-prisons is more cost-effective," says Renato Rivera, a senior analyst at the Global Initiative Against Transnational Organized Crime. Perez Guadalupe, a professor at Lima's Universidad del Pacifico, adds that UN standards dating to 1955 recommend medium-sized prisons of 1,000 to 2,000 inmates. "Mega-prisons, apart from being impersonal, can become extremely dangerous," he says; Rivera points to the widely reported 2021 massacres in Ecuador's largest, most crowded prisons.
Mass incarceration has coincided with a dramatic fall in violence in El Salvador and a stronger public sense of safety, and announcements of new mega-prisons project an image of a strong state confronting organized crime. But with reports of arbitrary arrests, abuses and more than 500 deaths in state custody, experts warn the symbolism does not guarantee sustainable results. Those require a "clear commitment" to external oversight, human rights protections and reintegration programs, Espinoza says. Perez Guadalupe calls the model "pure propaganda," says the CECOT images violate human dignity and argues the state must show "moral superiority over those who break the law."
El Salvador's case may also be hard to copy. Mass arrests under Bukele's state of emergency have given the country one of the world's highest incarceration rates, and CECOT was built to permanently hold members of gangs such as MS-13 and Barrio 18, considered extremely dangerous. Elsewhere, Perez Guadalupe argues, most prisoners eventually return to society, so the real question is "how we want them to leave: worse or better."
Alternatives exist on paper and in practice. The UN Nelson Mandela Rules, updated in 2015, make human dignity, an absolute ban on torture and degrading treatment, and social reintegration central to prison management. The region has its own innovations: Brazil's APAC facilities, run without guards, weapons or violence; Conflict Prevention and Resolution Committees in Argentina; and the Alternative Criminal Justice Center in Mexico's Sonora state. Experts see a role for smaller maximum security prisons for specific profiles, with more precise classification.
Above all, they emphasize, prisons address the consequences of organized crime, not its roots. Poverty, social exclusion and lack of opportunity demand public policies centered on employment, education and social integration in one of the world's most unequal regions.






