Tennessee Highway Patrol to Pay $70,000 to Ex-Pop Star in DUI Settlement
Blood tests confirmed Stefanie Fair was sober during her 2024 arrest, joining a growing list of claims against the state for erroneous drunk driving stops.
By Julian Lee ·

The Tennessee Highway Patrol will transfer $70,000 to Stefanie Fair, a former member of the 1990s pop group Wild Orchid, to settle her lawsuit regarding a 2024 drunk driving arrest. The state Board of Claims approved the agreement, and an attorney general’s office spokesman indicated the payout will occur within the next few weeks.
Blood work collected during the incident later established that Fair had no alcohol in her system at the time of the stop. The trooper involved, Keith Velez, claimed he detected a distinct odor of alcohol inside the vehicle. Fair, who was eating ice cream before the arrest according to video footage, stated she felt more afraid during the interaction with the officer than she did while in jail.
Legal experts suggest the settlement reflects a systemic issue within the agency. Ben Raybin, Fair’s attorney, argued that the state now recognizes many of these arrests are legally unsupportable. He noted that in Tennessee, sober drivers have no administrative recourse to recover costs after charges are dismissed, leaving a lawsuit as the only financial remedy.
Court records indicate a surge in similar lawsuits against the state. Fair is the second sober driver to reach a settlement with the Highway Patrol. Thomas Manis, who was arrested in East Tennessee, received a $75,000 payment for a similar incident.
Several other high-profile individuals are currently suing the state. These plaintiffs include NASA employee Labreesha Batey and former U.S. attorney Jane Bondurant. Records show that state trooper James Zahn arrested Bondurant while she was sober, marking her as the eighth such driver stopped by that specific officer. A man from Thompson Station filed a lawsuit in 2026 claiming Zahn arrested him while he was also sober, which would make him the ninth case.
The pattern of settlements extends beyond the Highway Patrol. The Rutherford County Sheriff’s Office and the La Vergne police department have also settled claims from sober drivers who were arrested for drunk driving. These legal actions highlight the financial and procedural challenges facing state law enforcement in Tennessee.
The approval of Fair’s settlement follows a period of increased scrutiny on DUI enforcement practices. The payments to Manis and Fair represent the first two resolved financial claims for sober drivers against the Highway Patrol. Other ongoing litigation suggests further settlements may follow as the state addresses these legal disputes.






