US and Iran settle into a costly standoff short of all-out war
Months after their truce collapsed, Washington and Tehran are trading limited strikes and economic blows in a frozen conflict that analysts say neither side can sustain indefinitely.
By Julian Lee ·

For months, Iran and the United States have weighed a return to outright war against persevering towards a negotiated peace. Instead, they appear to have settled on something in between: a grinding pattern of intermittent attacks and economic pressure that analysts say could carry on for months without escalating into all-out conflict.
The two countries have largely stopped short of full-blown military confrontation since July, when a June Memorandum of Understanding between them fell apart. Both have maintained blockades in and around the Strait of Hormuz, once the conduit for one-fifth of the world's oil and natural gas supplies. In recent days, Iran says it has targeted US military sites in Bahrain and Kuwait, while the United States carried out an air strike on Iran's Qeshm island on Tuesday. Tehran has also continued to target ships it says have not followed its rules for passing through the strait, as Washington stands firm on sanctions and its naval blockade of Iranian ports.
Sustaining this status quo means absorbing mounting economic and political costs that could eventually prove untenable, especially for Iran, analysts say. "The two sides have very different calculations about the costs of prolonging the confrontation," Hamidreza Azizi, senior Iran analyst at the International Crisis Group, told Al Jazeera. "As economic pressure mounts, Iran may become increasingly willing to take military risks to break the deadlock."
Washington's posture has appeared to shift following the ruling Republicans' crushing defeat by the opposition Democratic Party in this month's midterm elections, a loss that President Donald Trump and Vice President JD Vance have acknowledged the deeply unpopular Iran war was partly to blame for. Last week Trump said the war was "effectively over" militarily, though he warned he "would not hesitate" to resume strikes if diplomacy failed. Secretary of State Marco Rubio has suggested the US is pursuing economic rather than military pressure. "We don't need to conduct military strikes if we're achieving the same objective through economic means and economic pressure," Rubio said last week. "The economic pressure on Iran is going to get even worse."
Tehran has signalled it will not accept that limbo. Supreme Leader Mojtaba Khamenei has told officials to end the state of "neither war nor peace". "We will not remain in a state of 'neither war nor peace'," parliament speaker and top negotiator Mohammad Bagher Ghalibaf told parliament on Sunday. "It makes absolutely no difference to us whether the United States wants negotiations or war."
The economic fallout is already spreading. Iran's disruptions to shipping in the strait have triggered some of the most dramatic oil price fluctuations in years. In late October, Brent crude traded at $117 per barrel, its highest since it reached a four-year high in April. The benchmark, which stood at about $72 just before the war, has since fallen back to $92 as vessels brave the strait despite an uptick in attacks, but that remains 30 percent higher than before the war. US petrol now averages $3.80 per gallon, the lowest since March but well above the pre-war average of $2.98, according to the American Automobile Association. Diesel stood at just over $5.93 per gallon as of November 17, compared with $3.72 in February, a particular burden for American farmers and truckers, many of whom form the backbone of Trump's MAGA support base.
Ron Bousso, a Reuters columnist who analyses global energy markets, estimates that a drawn-out, low-grade conflict could "put a floor under oil prices" and force Gulf exporters to keep contending with massive freight and insurance costs. The danger, he wrote last week, is not simply another price surge but that the Middle East settles into "a conflict intense enough to keep shipping dangerous, insurance expensive and energy infrastructure vulnerable, but contained enough for the world to learn to live with it", leaving longer-term strain on US Gulf allies as global energy disruption becomes the "new normal".
The toll on Iran could be even more severe. Week after week, the US has introduced more sanctions against Iranian entities and those it says trade with them, while the naval blockade has made it increasingly difficult for Iran to export its oil. Mohammad Farzanegan, professor of Middle East economics at the Center for Near and Middle Eastern Studies, said Iran's government has continuously prioritised "short-term survival" over much-needed investment while its economy shrinks and its people face one of the world's highest inflation rates. Falling oil revenues, he said, "have introduced significant pressure on the government budget, increasing the need to raise taxes, reduce subsidies, especially on energy products, and plan painful economic reforms". Rouzbeh Parsi, an Iran analyst at Lund University, agreed that "Iran's population is suffering tremendously" and said "they bear the brunt of this economic war", adding: "While this is not sustainable, long term the question is, if it can hold until Trump leaves office."
The pressure also carries political risks on both sides. Azizi said Iran's leadership is "particularly concerned about the possibility of renewed domestic unrest", warning that letting the situation continue indefinitely "could gradually weaken the economy, increase domestic instability and undermine the government's position". Farzanegan said any new major shock "could ignite a new round of violent protests", and that it is unclear how long the government can maintain stability under such fragile conditions. For Washington, the standoff undercuts Trump's core campaign pledge of no new foreign wars and keeps alive a conflict that more than 70 percent of Americans want to end, according to a Reuters/Ipsos poll on November 9. Azizi also raised "the question of credibility", noting the US has been unable to compel Iran to abandon control of the strait or accept its terms.
Analysts say both sides have reasons to escalate. Iran's government, Azizi said, "may eventually conclude that deliberately escalating the confrontation is preferable to allowing its economic and strategic position to deteriorate further". Parsi, meanwhile, said Trump's blistering midterm defeat has "removed the last consideration we all thought would hold him back from a full-scale war". Trump could still let sanctions run their course, he added, but if he comes to believe another military attack "will spell the end of the Islamic republic, or simply wants revenge, this 'not-peace' could easily become a full war".






