Wisconsin's 12-to-1 Arrest Gap
A student-led panel at the University of Wisconsin-Madison challenged a plan to cut jail capacity by 188 beds, citing the state's extreme racial disparity in arrests.
By Julian Lee ·

The consolidation of Dane County's jail facilities faces criticism from a new student organization that argues the plan reduces capacity while the state maintains one of the nation's widest racial gaps in arrests.
Shar-ron Buie, data and evaluation coordinator for the Dane County Office of Justice and Reform, presented data at a panel on October 7 showing that Black Wisconsinites are 12 times more likely to be arrested than white residents. She identified this ratio as the second-highest disparity in the United States.
Ion Meyn, a law professor at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, contextualized the current figures by comparing them to historical rates. He noted that the incarceration rate in the 1820s was 1 in 10, implying that the current 1 in 12 ratio indicates a deterioration in outcomes. "It means we are doing worse than Jim Crow," Meyn said.
James Morgan, a community organizer with Madison Organizing in Strength, Equity and Solidarity for Criminal Legal System Reform, described language as "the currency of power." He argued that institutions use favorable terminology to obscure exploitation and urged the audience to examine who shapes the policies of elected officials.
The Dane County jail consolidation project proposes merging outdated downtown facilities into a new tower attached to the Public Safety building. The plan reduces the bed count from 1,013 to 825 and seeks to eliminate or reduce solitary confinement. Morgan characterized the new facility as "totally inadequate" for those with mental health issues and alcoholism.
Benjamin Gonring, Wisconsin Public Defender, highlighted recidivism data from 2016, where the gap between 20- to 24-year-olds and those over 45 was 24.5%. He stated that young people require investment and at least one mentor to define their potential.
Morgan also addressed the role of university rules, specifically statutes requiring a share of supplies to be produced through prison labor via Badger State Industries. He called for exposing these systems, establishing a living wage, and improving reintegration practices. Meyn concluded by stating that publicizing crimes is racist and harmful.
More World · Madison news · Report a business · Got a Story?






